TRUEclaimsCheck your car's value

Will my car be totaled in Vermont?

The short answer

Vermont doesn't set a percentage for insured cars. Insurers generally use the Total Loss Formula: a car is a total loss when the repair cost plus its salvage value reaches its actual cash value (ACV).

Total Loss Formula (repairs + salvage ≥ value)23 V.S.A. § 2001(13)-(14)
Check what you're owed, free Body shop? Check any car

How Vermont decides a total loss

Vermont doesn't set a percentage for insured cars. Insurers generally use the Total Loss Formula: a car is a total loss when the repair cost plus its salvage value reaches its actual cash value (ACV).

Salvage value is what the damaged car would sell for as it is, to a rebuilder or a parts buyer. Because it's part of the math, a car with a high salvage value can be totaled even when the repair estimate seems reasonable.

Rule reference: 23 V.S.A. § 2001(13)-(14). This is general information, not legal advice; the insurer makes the final call.

An example

Say a car was worth $20,000 and the wreck would sell for $5,000 as salvage. Repairs of $15,000 or more would bring repairs plus salvage to the car's value, so it would likely be totaled.

Car's value
$20,000
Salvage value
$5,000
Repairs that likely total it
$15,000+

Illustrative example.

What can change the outcome

  • Hidden damage. Estimates often grow once the car is taken apart, which can push a car near the line over it.
  • The car's value. A low valuation lowers the line. Check that the comparable cars match your car's trim, options and mileage.
  • Its age. Older cars are worth less, so the same repair is a bigger share of their value.
  • Salvage value. A higher salvage value totals a car sooner under the formula.

If your car is totaled in Vermont

  1. Ask the insurer for the full valuation report, so you can see how the number was reached.
  2. Check the comparable cars: same trim, similar miles, near you.
  3. Don't rush to sign or accept payment until the offer makes sense.
  4. If you disagree with the value, check your policy for an Appraisal Clause. It lets either side ask for an appraisal with your own insurer, without a lawsuit.

If your car was repaired instead, it may have lost resale value. That's called diminished value, and in many states you can claim it from the at-fault driver's insurer.

See what your car is really worth

Free valuation from real comparable vehicles, and help from a vetted appraiser or law firm if you want it.

Check what you're owed, free

For body shops in Vermont

Know whether a car will total before your team tears it down: enter the vehicle, the owner's ZIP and your repair estimate, and see the car's value from comparable vehicles nearby, its salvage value, and whether it's likely totaled, borderline or likely repaired under Vermont's rule.

Check any car free

Questions people ask

›What is the total loss threshold in Vermont?

Vermont doesn't set a percentage for insured cars. Insurers generally use the Total Loss Formula: a car is a total loss when the repair cost plus its salvage value reaches its actual cash value (ACV).

›How do I know if my car will be totaled in Vermont?

Compare the repair estimate with the car's value. Say a car was worth $20,000 and the wreck would sell for $5,000 as salvage. Repairs of $15,000 or more would bring repairs plus salvage to the car's value, so it would likely be totaled. Estimates often grow once the car is taken apart, so a car close to the line can still be totaled.

›How is my totaled car's value decided?

The insurer pays the actual cash value (ACV), usually from a valuation report built on comparable vehicles for sale, with adjustments for mileage, options and condition. You can ask for that report and check whether the comparable cars really match yours.

›Can I dispute a total loss offer in Vermont?

Many auto policies include an Appraisal Clause: when you and your own insurer disagree on the value, either side can ask for an appraisal, each picks an independent appraiser, and an umpire decides if they can't agree. It applies to claims with your own insurer, and policy wording varies, so read yours.

›What if my car was repaired instead?

A car with an accident on its history usually sells for less, even after a good repair. That loss is called diminished value. In many states you can claim it from the at-fault driver's insurer; the rules vary by state.

Total loss rules in other states

New to total losses? Read the plain-English guide.